The Law · The term

“Nobody Can Sue at All?” Gorsuch Asked the Government

Justice Gorsuch asked the government that question at the term’s first argument. Two later cases, on privacy and pensions, also ask who may sue.

KC
By Karen Campbell · December 2026 · 9 min read

WASHINGTON — The Supreme Court began its term on Oct. 5 with eight justices on the bench and a question that Monsanto’s lawyers had answered in their favor 102 days earlier.

On June 25, in Monsanto v. Durnell, the court threw out a Missouri jury’s failure-to-warn verdict over the weedkiller Roundup, 7 to 2. Justice Brett M. Kavanaugh wrote that because the Environmental Protection Agency had approved a label without a cancer warning, a state jury could not require one. Justice Ketanji Brown Jackson dissented, joined by Justice Neil M. Gorsuch.

The first case of the new term, Suncor Energy v. County Commissioners of Boulder County, asked a version of the same question about a different industry: when federal law governs a field, how much of it is left for state courts?

Justice Samuel A. Alito Jr. did not take part. A clerk’s letter on Sept. 28 said he had withdrawn from the case, and gave no reason. A 4-4 split would leave the Colorado Supreme Court’s ruling in place and set no precedent.


Boulder sued in 2018 under Colorado law, raising state tort and consumer protection claims. It asked the oil companies to pay for the local costs of climate change. The companies spent years trying to move the case to federal court and lost, including a denial of review by the Supreme Court in 2023. The Colorado Supreme Court then ruled against them in 2025. In February, the justices agreed to hear the case and added a question of their own: whether the court has jurisdiction to hear the appeal at this stage.

The argument turned on two terms that are easily confused. When Congress legislates on a subject, it displaces any federal common law judges had developed there. That happens automatically. Preemption, which is what federal law does to state law, does not; it requires a conflict or a clear statement from Congress, and the presumption favors the states.

The oil companies’ position collapses the two. Interstate pollution, they argue, was never a matter for state law, and when the Clean Air Act displaced federal common law, nothing fell back to Colorado.

Justice Gorsuch put the consequence to Sarah Harris, the principal deputy solicitor general, who argued for the United States. Before the Clean Air Act, he said, Boulder could have sued under federal common law. Because of the act, and because Congress did not address the question, did that mean “nobody can sue at all?”

“Again, I think that’s correct,” Harris said.

Kannon Shanmugam argued for Suncor and Exxon, and Kevin Russell for Boulder. Justice Elena Kagan was dubious of the oil companies’ arguments. She asked Shanmugam where the support was for the argument that the Constitution reserves the subject to federal law. “This suit appears to be based on the old 1990s tobacco suits,” she said, and the opioid litigation followed the same model. “This is chapter 3. So, if this is chapter 3, were chapters 1 and 2 also preempted?” Shanmugam said it was “a different book.”

Justice Kavanaugh cited four precedents and said they treat interstate air and water pollution as matters for federal law unless Congress specifically preserves state law. He called the idea that Congress revived state tort law with the Clean Air Act “an all-time elephant in mousehole.”

He also raised International Paper Co. v. Ouellette, decided in 1987, in which Vermont lakefront owners sued a New York paper mill. The court held that the Clean Water Act barred suits under the law of the affected state, Vermont, but allowed suits under the law of the source state, New York. That distinction runs through the argument.

Justice Clarence Thomas raised the jurisdiction question at the outset, in questions to both Suncor’s counsel and the government’s.

Chief Justice John G. Roberts Jr. asked what would follow a Boulder victory. “A municipality in every single state will file a lawsuit,” he said. The oil companies told the court that nearly 60 state and local governments have filed similar suits.

With Justice Alito out, Boulder needs only four votes to prevail, and the court could also resolve the case on jurisdiction. Boulder’s claims include deception. For lawyers who plead consumer protection counts against regulated industries, that is the part to watch.


Salazar v. Paramount Global (argued Oct. 14)

In 1987, a reporter for the Washington City Paper obtained Robert H. Bork’s video rental history while he was a Supreme Court nominee, and the paper wrote about his choices. A year later Congress passed the Video Privacy Protection Act, which sets damages of $2,500 per violation.

Then came the Meta Pixel, code that lets websites share visitors’ Facebook identities with the company. Michael Salazar subscribed to a free newsletter from 247Sports, a Paramount site, and says the site shared his video-viewing activity with Facebook. He sued, and a divided Sixth Circuit upheld dismissal, ruling that a newsletter subscriber is not a “consumer” under the act. The circuits are split on the question.

Joshua Hammack, arguing for Salazar in his first Supreme Court argument, urged the justices to read “consumer” to cover any consumer of a video provider’s goods or services, not only its audiovisual ones. Paul D. Clement, for Paramount, argued that a newsletter subscriber is not a consumer of audiovisual materials. The justices appeared inclined to side with Salazar.

Justices Kavanaugh and Kagan both said companies can avoid liability by getting consent. Justice Barrett questioned whether Salazar has standing, since his information was not disclosed to a person. Clement offered to provide additional briefing.

Anderson v. Intel (argued Oct. 6)

Intel’s 401(k) plan committee put portions of employees’ target-date and diversified funds into hedge funds and private equity. The employees say the investments lagged the market. The Ninth Circuit affirmed dismissal because the complaint did not identify a “meaningful benchmark,” a comparator with similar aims and strategies.

The employees argued that the benchmark rule is out of step with federal pleading standards and ends such cases before discovery. The rule dates to Meiners v. Wells Fargo, an Eighth Circuit decision from 2018, and has spread to other circuits.

The justices appeared receptive to a meaningful-benchmark requirement. The open questions were what makes a benchmark meaningful and whether the court should define it.

Hoffmann v. WBI Energy (argued Nov. 9)

Leonard Hoffmann is a landowner in McKenzie County, N.D. In 2018, WBI Energy used federal eminent domain to take parts of his property and his neighbors’ for a 12-mile, 24-inch gas pipeline. The owners and WBI settled the price of the easements, and the owners then sought about $383,000 in attorney fees and expenses under North Dakota law. The Eighth Circuit ruled that WBI did not have to pay them. The courts of appeals are divided. The Solicitor General is arguing alongside WBI.

Robert McNamara of the Institute for Justice argued for the landowners. Several justices questioned why WBI should not follow federal standards, under which it would not have to pay fees.

Apple v. Epic Games (granted June 30)

The court agreed on June 30 to decide whether a party can be held in contempt for violating the “spirit” of an injunction when the order does not name the conduct. Apple says the courts of appeals are split on the standard; Epic says they are not. The court declined to review Apple’s challenge to the injunction’s reach beyond Epic.

Younge v. Fulton County (argued Nov. 2)

Dr. Jasmine Younge was a deputy chief of staff in the Fulton County district attorney’s office. She says she was fired in 2019 after telling the office she was pregnant. The office raised the “personal staff” exemption to Title VII for the first time at summary judgment. The question is whether Rule 8(c), which says affirmative defenses “must” be pleaded, requires a motion to amend. The circuits are divided.


The court will not issue opinions in these cases for months. Suncor is the one to watch for anyone who sues an industry. When it comes down, the question is how the opinion treats source-state law, the point Justice Kavanaugh raised.

Miller v. McDonald, No. 26-438, is a pending petition, not a granted case; the response is due Dec. 2. Argument quotes come from the transcripts on supremecourt.gov and press coverage of the arguments. Siri & Glimstad, counsel on the Miller petition, has a business relationship with Oliver & Ginger, which publishes Plaintiff’s Brief.

Sources

Transcripts: Suncor, Oct. 5 · Salazar, Oct. 14 and Anderson, Oct. 6 (supremecourt.gov/oral_arguments/argument_transcripts/2026/). Dockets: 25-170 · 25-459 · 25-498 · 25-159 · 25-1311 · 25-352 · 26-438. Monsanto v. Durnell summary · Ouellette · Meiners v. Wells Fargo · Bloomberg Law on Hammack, Oct. 12 · PLANSPONSOR on Anderson · Legal Planet on Suncor · SCOTUSblog OT2026.

Next story
Ethics

The Demand Letter to Michael Flatley That Became an Extortion Case

Riverdance’s former lead dancer was the target. The California Supreme Court ruled on it in 2006, and its rules reach every lawyer who represents a survivor.

Back to The Law

Get Plaintiff’s Brief by email