The fine came from a simple count. In November and December 2021, New York’s Department of Health audited three Amish schools for compliance with the state’s school immunization law. At one, Dygert Road School, it counted 26 students with no proof of vaccination. At another, Pleasant View School, also called Twin Mountain School, it counted 23. The state treats each day an unvaccinated child attends school as a violation, and each violation carries a fine of up to $2,000. The department assumed each child had been out of compliance for one day. Twenty-six times $2,000 is $52,000. Twenty-three times $2,000 is $46,000.
The third school, Shady Lane, gave the department no documentation for its students. The department assumed that one student had been out of compliance for at least ten days. Ten days at $2,000 is $20,000. The total is $118,000. The state’s health commissioner called the fines “principled and conservative under the circumstances.” In its own filing, the department said its method “was very generous to the Respondents,” the complaint says.
The schools say they will not vaccinate their students and will not move them to homeschooling. They say the fines, and the threat of more, will shut the schools down. They have lost in federal district court and twice in the Second Circuit, most recently on June 30, 2026. On Sept. 28 they asked the Supreme Court to hear the case. New York’s response is due Dec. 2. The justices have not decided whether to take it.
Who is asking
The petitioners are the three one-room schools, Ezra Wengerd, whom the courts describe as an elected representative of all Amish schools in New York, and two fathers who sit on school boards, Joseph Miller and Jonas Smucker. The petition says the schools are funded solely by the Amish, sit on Amish land and teach only Amish children. The complaint says they take no state money and sit on land the community owns. Aaron Siri, a lawyer on the petition, puts the number of Amish in New York at about 25,000. Straight Arrow News reported the same figure on Sept. 2. Miller lives in Clymer, in Chautauqua County, and his children attend an Amish-run school there, the complaint says. All three schools are in Chautauqua County.
Their complaint says the Amish faith calls for a self-reliant way of life apart from the modern world, and that many Amish hold deep religious objections to vaccines. The schools do not require proof of vaccination because the parents “have sincerely held religious beliefs which do not permit them to inject” their children, the complaint says. The families say homeschooling is not an option, because learning in a group is a vital part of their children’s spiritual development.
“Only the Supreme Court can save the Amish in New York now.”
Hiram Sasser, First Liberty Institute, to Straight Arrow News, Sept. 2, 2026
The hearing
The state mailed charges to the three schools on March 11, 2022. A hearing followed on May 2 in Fonda, in Montgomery County, before an administrative law judge, Natalie Bordeaux. The Amish came in person. The judge and the state’s lawyers joined by video.
Wengerd spoke for the schools. “First of all, I want to thank God for the freedom that we still have,” he began, according to the complaint, which cites the hearing recording. He read a written statement. In it he asked the state to restore the exemption: “We plead with you + beg for pardon + grace with the help of God.” He said the schools are church-run and take no state aid, and that homeschooling is not an option: “We love our state of N.Y. + have no desire to move out.” The complaint says he also told the hearing that Amish families would choose prison or a martyr’s death before going against their convictions.
The department’s lawyer answered that no provision of the law lets an unvaccinated child attend school on a non-medical exemption. On May 25, Bordeaux found that all three schools had broken the law. She recommended no penalty, because the schools had not been given enough notice of the requirements. The department objected on June 21. It wrote that the schools had said they would keep violating the law. On Dec. 15, 2022, it adopted her findings and rejected her recommendation. It wrote that it “does not doubt the genuineness” of the schools’ religious claims, the complaint says, but that the Legislature had removed the exemption. The cover letter gave the schools 30 days to pay.
The law
New York has regulated school immunization since 1860, according to the Second Circuit, which says it was the second state to do so. A 1966 law exempted children who could not be vaccinated for medical reasons and children whose parents held religious objections. The state kept both exemptions until 2019.
In 2018 and 2019 the country had its worst measles outbreak in more than 25 years, and New York was the center of it, the court wrote. Most cases were in communities with clusters of unvaccinated people. In six schools in Rockland County, up to 20% of students had religious exemptions. Legislators cited one case in particular: city health officials traced 44 measles cases, including 26 students with religious exemptions, to a single child with a religious exemption. On June 13, 2019, the legislature repealed the religious exemption and kept the medical one. A school may not let a child attend more than 14 days without proof of the required vaccines.
The courts
The Amish plaintiffs sued on June 2, 2023. Chief Judge Elizabeth Wolford of the Western District of New York dismissed the case. She applied a Second Circuit decision, We The Patriots v. Connecticut Office of Early Childhood Development, that upheld Connecticut’s repeal of its religious exemption. The Second Circuit affirmed on March 3, 2025. The Supreme Court then vacated that ruling and sent the case back for another look in light of Mahmoud v. Taylor, a 2025 decision that said Wisconsin v. Yoder is not confined to its facts.
The Second Circuit ruled again on June 30. In an unsigned opinion from a panel of Judges José Cabranes, Richard Wesley and Eunice Lee, it held that “Mahmoud does not change the result.” The court wrote that the immunization law “does not regulate what children are taught” and sets a health-and-safety condition on attending school in person. “The burden may be serious,” the court wrote, “but it is not the kind of state interference” that triggered strict scrutiny in Yoder or Mahmoud.
The court also rejected the argument that the law is not neutral because it allows medical exemptions but not religious ones. The medical exemption is narrower, it said: it covers a specific vaccine and must be reissued each year, while the old religious exemption covered every vaccine for as long as the child was admitted.
What the petition asks
The petition asks the Court three things: whether the law violates the Free Exercise Clause for Amish parents under Mahmoud; whether New York may refuse religious exemptions while allowing secular ones; and whether the Court should reconsider Employment Division v. Smith, the 1990 decision that neutral, generally applicable laws do not need religious exemptions. Shannon Denmark of Washington is counsel of record. Lawyers from First Liberty Institute and Siri & Glimstad, including Aaron Siri, Elizabeth Brehm and Walker Moller, also signed.
By Nov. 2, 23 friend-of-the-court briefs were on the docket. One is from Alabama, joined by 16 other states and the Arizona Legislature. Another is from Old Order Amish Bishop Elmer Stoltzfus. The Amish say a loss could lead many to leave New York, Straight Arrow News reported. It is not clear where they would go.
What to watch
The case matters beyond these three schools. If the Court takes it, its answer will tell lower courts how far a parent’s religious claim goes when the state’s rule is a health condition and not a lesson, and how to compare a religious exemption with a medical one. Its answer on Smith would change the starting point for every free-exercise claim.
New York’s response is due Dec. 2. The attorney general’s office represents the health commissioner, Dr. James McDonald. After the State responds, the petition goes to the justices.
If the justices decline the case, the Second Circuit’s ruling stands, and so do the fines.
Siri & Glimstad, whose lawyers signed the petition, has a business relationship with Oliver & Ginger, which publishes Plaintiff’s Brief. Facts are from the verified complaint filed June 2, 2023, the Second Circuit’s June 30, 2026 opinion, the petition, the Supreme Court docket and Straight Arrow News.
Sources
Verified Complaint, Miller v. McDonald, No. 1:23-cv-00484 (W.D.N.Y. filed June 2, 2023), ECF No. 1 · Miller v. McDonald, No. 24-681 (2d Cir. June 30, 2026) and 130 F.4th 258 (2d Cir. Mar. 3, 2025) · Petition for certiorari, No. 26-438, Sept. 28, 2026 · Supreme Court docket, No. 26-438, read Nov. 10, 2026 · Brief of Alabama et al. as amici, Nov. 2, 2026 · Straight Arrow News, Eva Fedderly, Sept. 2, 2026